Drop a Needle Enough Times and You Get Pi
A French naturalist asked the question in 1733 and answered it in 1777. The answer involves π for no obvious reason.
Rule a sheet with parallel lines a fixed distance d apart. Drop a needle of length L (where L ≤ d) onto the sheet at random. What is the probability the needle crosses one of the lines?
Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon — naturalist, director of the Jardin du Roi, author of the 36-volume Histoire Naturelle — posed this question in 1733 and worked on it intermittently for forty-four years. His solution appeared in the fourth supplement to the Histoire in 1777, in a section titled Essai d'Arithmétique Morale. The answer is 2L / (πd). When L = d, that simplifies to 2/π, about 0.6366.
The derivation is one of those calculations that looks like a card trick the first time. Let θ be the angle between the needle and the lines, distributed uniformly on [0, π]. Let x be the distance from the needle's center to the nearest line, uniform on [0, d/2]. The needle crosses a line iff x ≤ (L/2) sin θ. Integrate the indicator over the joint uniform density and the answer is 2L/(πd). π enters through the integral of sin θ, which is rooted in the fact that orientation is rotationally symmetric — there is no preferred direction in which to drop a needle.
That last point is what makes the result more than a curio. Buffon had founded a sub-field. Geometric probability — probability over continuous geometric configurations — became its own area, with Laplace extending the needle to a grid of perpendicular lines in 1812 and Crofton building it into integral geometry in the 1860s.
You can use the formula in reverse: drop n needles, count k crossings, estimate π ≈ 2nL / (kd). It works, slowly. Convergence is roughly as 1/√n, which is why nobody computes π this way for real. The interesting part is that you can.
Make Recess yours.
Sign in to save the ones you loved, never see the same thing twice, and tell us what you want more of.